Showing posts with label Bishops Behaving Bodaciously. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bishops Behaving Bodaciously. Show all posts

Goodman: The problem with bishops' "neutrality" argument


Bl. Von Galen, The Lion of Münster
Patron of Bishops who wont be shut up
Will Goodman of the Servants of Our Lady of Guadalupe sent this on. 

+A response to an article I posted on CNN.com. Pray for those who profess to have faith in Christ the King and helped put the most notoriously pro-abortion president back in the White House.

Recently CNN ran an article entitled: "
My Take: Catholic bishops' election behavior threatens their authority" by Vincent Miller who is the Gudorf Chair of Catholic Theology and Culture at the University of Dayton.

This article was interesting in some ways, and in other ways– quite sad.

The author makes a very important point when he states:

"Voters must weigh the mix of positions of both candidates, not just the objections against one."

No candidate or party is perfect. Honest critiques of any political party failing on a clear matter of justice are not only fair, but obligatory.

This is another good point:

"(The bishops) must beware the divisiveness that even the appearance of partisanship can bring into the Church."

This is a real consideration to always keep in mind, but it can be quite challenging however, when a particular party or candidate has aligned itself with the promotion of grave evils intrinsically at odds with both the common good and the dignity of individual human persons. In an essentially two-party, bi-cameral political system when one party has taken a radical and dangerous position against the common good- speaking out against such injustice is what is required, even though it may be perceived as 'partisan' by some.

I am thankful Bl. Von Galen, Bishop of Munster Germany, spoke out against Hitler (more than his political rival) because the evil of racist eugenics behind Nazism had to be directly confronted. History looks back upon such acts as heroic, not partisan. This is because the evil being confronted was so great.

Bishop Jenky, cited in the article, is cut of this same cloth, in my opinion, speaking out– not against policy– but against moral evil.

The article does not seem to recognize that certain intrinsic evils can never, ever be promoted by any candidate or political party: the taking of innocent life (viz., euthanasia, abortion, human embryonic research, cloning research, etc.), attempts to re-define marriage, and removing the protections of religious liberty and the rights of conscience on the very subjects of life, death and faith. Why was this omitted? The author reduces the concern of the HHS mandate to a mere trifle of defining a "religious exemption". Much more is at stake! For example- the involvement of the Church and all people of good will in early chemical abortions– because they are being _forced_ by the Federal Government. This is outrageous! And it won't be settled by a broader exemption.

The author points out concerns about Ryan's policy and that is fine (...although I am not sure if he accurately portrayed Ryan's view on Medicare). Catholics are free to debate policy, and this is a welcome opportunity for dialogue and appreciation for differences in opinion in how to handle certain social and governmental problems. My experience has been that bishops encourage the laity to be informed and make their personal decisions as best as they can. This isn't the issue though.

The central point the US Bishops were making in this election is that there are some evils so great that they cannot be considered "policy" upon which good people may disagree.

Bishop Morlino in Madison thus taught that no Catholic with a well-formed conscience can ever vote for a candidate who supports abortion, the redefinition of marriage, and assaults on religious liberty/rights of conscience. This is because such evils are not merely "political policy"- but violations of the natural moral law upon which all of society must be based. (Read- "self-evident truths".) Bl. Von Galen could not tell faithful Catholics in the late 1930s that they can "bracket" Nazi eugenics and still support Nazi candidates because of their other policies– and still be "good Catholics". Some evils are just too big to set to the side when considering a candidate. Some evils are so great that a good bishop must warn the faithful not to participate in such evil– even by a simple vote. (Note- Hitler was elected by democratic vote. Were those Catholics who helped put him in office honoring Christ by such a vote?! It seems impossible.)

There is a hierarchy of justice. Care for the poor is an essential element of justice. But it will always be a concern beneath the killing of the poor. The order of justice is as important as accessing the elements of justice that are related to political realities. The most fundamental rights of the human person are always at the top of such a hierarchy- and hence, first in the order of justice. The right to life is the most fundamental human right and therefore on the up-most rung of the hierarchy of justice. The bishops are trying to teach this crucial lesson and our author does not seem to recognize this was at issue.

In the final analysis, I am very troubled and saddened that one who heads a department of theology at a Catholic university would have written this piece on how members of the Church may be perceived without mentioning what the bishops were actually doing to serve Christ and His flock and those threatened by the greatest injustices in our nation.

It is for these and other reasons that we pray for Catholics who supported Obama/Biden, as well as those who, (perhaps like this author?), would prefer the bishops to be more silent to the gravity of certain moral evils in order to be perceived as more politically "neutral".

StarTribune: We disagree with DVD, but Church has a right to advocate

From Stella Borealis
Now that you picked yourself up off of the floor, it is 669 words! Thank you Star Tribune!!

Last update: October 7, 2010 - 6:09 PM

The old advice "Don't discuss religion or politics" has been discarded since it was announced that Catholic bishops were mailing a DVD opposing same-sex marriage to 400,000 Minnesotans. Supporters have been vocal in appreciation for their church's full-throated articulation of its values. Detractors have been just as emphatic denouncing what they see as misplaced priorities and improper politicking.

Talk-show phone lines are burning up, and the controversy has generated more letters to the editor than any news since another mixture of religion, politics and gay rights, just weeks ago: Target Corp.'s donation to a group supporting Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer.

Passions arise because this is an issue that speaks to people's core values -- sacred, secular or both. While even Emmer insists that this year's gubernatorial campaign is about fiscal, not social, issues, the possible redefinition of marriage looms as a profound danger -- or opportunity -- for many Minnesotans.

This editorial board has clearly and consistently opposed the kind of state constitutional amendment -- defining marriage as being between one man and one woman -- that Archbishop John Nienstedt is calling for. We reaffirm that opposition today.

But while we strongly differ with the church's position, our support for freedom of speech and religion remains unshaken. So we also disagree with those who have called for the Catholic Church to lose its tax-exempt status due to the political nature of its DVD. Religious organizations are given this status because of what they do in the community, not because of what's said from the pulpit. Like other denominations, the Catholic Church is the equivalent of the Red Cross in the eyes of the Internal Revenue Service.

The church's tax-exempt status could be threatened if it directly endorsed candidates. But instead it's endorsing a policy outcome that's entirely consistent with its theology, in the same way Catholics have campaigned for decades to outlaw abortion.

Advocacy is nothing new to the Catholic Church or many other religious groups. Clerics have historically been at the forefront of politics in debates over (among other things) slavery, child labor, prohibition, obscenity in books and films, civil rights, Roe vs. Wade, the war in Vietnam and the war in Iraq. Many of today's critics may have been quite comfortable, even pleased, in 2005 when Nienstedt's predecessor, Harry Flynn, wrote and testified publicly against Gov. Tim Pawlenty's no-new-taxes policy. "The taxes we pay," the archbishop declared, "allow us to meet our moral responsibility toward our fellow citizens, our brothers and sisters in the family of God, who need our help to live in accordance with their God-given dignity."

Nienstedt may be getting more pushback than Flynn did, including from a significant number of Catholics. Attitudes about same-sex relationships are evolving. An Oct. 6 Pew poll reports that 42 percent of Americans are in favor of allowing same-sex marriage, up sharply from even last year, when the same poll said 37 percent were in favor. And on this issue the generation gap becomes a gulf, with 53 percent of those in so-called "Generation X" (born between 1965 and 1980) in favor, compared with 29 percent in the so-called "Silent Generation" (born between 1928 and 1945).

If these trends continue, future generations may see opposition to same-sex marriage the way today's Americans see segregation.

The DVD also comes amid a national conversation about the messages society sends to young people struggling with their sexuality. Too often the message is rejection and the result is tragedy, as in the devastating death of Rutgers University student Tyler Clementi, who took his own life after being "outed" by his roommate via social media, and in the suicides of some who have been bullied at school.

The perceived insensitivity of the DVD in such a climate may cost Catholics some parishioners. Others will be inspired to see their church sailing into the headwinds of unsettling social change. As always, each individual must decide what conscience dictates. But a free society should respect the Catholic Church's right to advocate for its principles. StarTribune
Weeeeeell, I agree with Ray that this is somewhat fair for a secularist, but really they use the opportunity to try and sell homosexual "marriage" (or really non-sexual marriage since two people of the same gender cannot have intercourse).  I think the great GK Chesterton said it best:

"Fallacies do not cease to be fallacies because they become fashions" --G K Chesterton

Listecki: Abortion is premier social justice issue

October is Respect Life month. This draws our attention to the need to protect all life from the moment of conception to natural death.

The last 100 years has produced two true world champions in the area of respect life, Blessed Mother Teresa of Calcutta and Pope John Paul II.

The image of Mother Teresa holding an infant and staring into the face of the child is ingrained in my mind. Perhaps that was the image that John Paul had in his mind when he wrote in The Gospel of Life, “It is the proclamation of a living God who is close to us, who calls us to profound communion with himself and awakens in us the certain hope of eternal life. It is the affirmation of the inseparable connection between the person, his life and his bodiliness. It is the presentation of human life as a life of relationship, a gift of God, the fruit and the sign of his love. It is the proclamation that Jesus has a unique relationship with every person, which enables us to see in every human face the face of Christ.” (81)

The campaigns leading up to the Nov. 2 elections are well underway, and much of the focus is on the economy and jobs. I do get it. “It’s the economy, stupid!” as one political commentator has stated.[....he must have misquoted Dad29 there] However, as followers of Jesus Christ, we cannot forget the life issues. They are essential to a just society.

Many people will criticize the Catholic Church’s position as disproportionately “pro life.” It’s obvious to me that we can’t even begin to address other social issues unless there is a life to be concerned about; for us, abortion is the premier social justice issue.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church states: “Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception. From the first moment of his existence, a human being must be recognized as having the rights of a person – among which is the right of every innocent being to life (2270).”

True reform in our society must begin with an attitude which respects human life. Of course, John Paul characterized this attitude as the shaping of a Culture of Life. Our current society promotes a narcissistic culture, which explains why we are more concerned with pleasing ourselves and our needs apart from needs of others. (If you remember, Narcissus was a Greek youth who fell in love with his own image.)

The pleasure and convenience of our society seems to be more important than the concern for our future generations and the abuses imposed on human life. It is difficult for our modern society to see the image of God imprinted in each human being because it is blinded by its own false image of perfection built on the destruction of the innocent.

For instance, it’s easy to justify the use of human embryos in scientific experimentation when we fail to see that a human life is being used, manipulated and destroyed. A new type of slavery is being established right under our noses by scientific technology that uses human embryos as a means to an end. No matter how noble the end may be, it cannot justify the taking of innocent human life and if it does, we are all at risk.

Many slave owners claimed that their economic development needed slavery. Many offered that the slave was property and not a human being in order to soothe troubled consciences. The Nazis rationalized that the Jews sent to concentration camps were not persons and therefore not subject to humane treatment; the noble purpose was the purification of the human race.

Today, some claim that embryos are just cells. They do so in order to abdicate their responsibility in the taking of human life. But even from a scientific perspective, there is little doubt about the fact that this is a distinct human life. This is just one of the many issues that we confront in our commitment to defend life at all stages.

As people of faith, we understand the significance of the Incarnation. The word was made flesh and dwelt among us. It is the divine nature of the Son of God in union with the human nature of Jesus Christ. He was like us in all things but sin. Every moment of life has been made sacred by our Creator. Science affirms the imprint of a distinct human life, but revelation allows us to see its sacredness.

The attacks on human life occur in many areas – procured abortion, embryonic stem cell experimentation, human sexuality, procreation, euthanasia and others. We must be informed about the teaching of our faith in the areas of human life. As a church, we hold that our respect is not merely from our system of beliefs but that it is grounded in the natural law which calls us to affirm the uniqueness of human life and the dignity inherent in each person.

As political candidates make campaign promises to create jobs and fix the national debt, let us, as Catholics, challenge them to achieve their goals with a profound respect for human life, ensuring the dignity of life in our laws from the moment of conception to natural death. In sharing the Gospel of Life during this Respect Life month, may our prayers, teachings and actions assist our nation in building a culture of life.
Milwaukee Herald