Showing posts with label Bishop Freking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bishop Freking. Show all posts

Final claim dismissed in La Crosse Diocese fraud suit


Bishop Raymond L. Burke, Bishop John Paul,
and Bishop Frederick Freking
A judge dismissed the last of three legal claims Tuesday against the Roman Catholic Diocese of La Crosse in a 2008 lawsuit that accused the diocese of covering up sex abuse allegations against a priest.

In keeping with his earlier rulings, La Crosse County Circuit Judge Scott Horne said the plaintiff, Brenda Varga, failed to demonstrate fraud and that her attorneys shaded facts in their complaint to get before the courts and fish for more information to support "a questionable lawsuit."

The diocese issued a statement saying in part, "This case illustrates the procedural difficulties in allowing the filing of old claims, particularly where plaintiff's lawyers are willing to make misrepresentations of fact to the court. ... The willingness to take liberties with the requisite facts in a case such as this does not further, and in fact deprecates, founded and credible claims of sexual assault and fraud."

According to the complaint, Varga, 49, met the late Rev. Raymond Bornbach in 1971 when her family attended a wedding at his church. She said he later befriended the third-grader's family, bought her gifts and molested her over the course of a year.

The church removed Bornbach from the ministry in 2004 after a diocesan review panel found Varga's allegations credible though Bornbach's attorney denied them. Bornbach died in 2006.

Varga's suit alleged then-Bishop Frederick Freking knew Bornbach had a proclivity for young girls when he was assigned to St. Michael's Parish in Hewitt, Wis. It made three claims of fraud.

According to the complaint - which Horne deemed "sloppily drafted, at best" - a parishioner told Freking in 1968 that his wife had witnessed Bornbach "touching a little girl inappropriately." But his testimony in depositions painted a different picture.

La Crosse Diocese fraud suit moves ahead

A fraud lawsuit against the Roman Catholic Diocese of La Crosse that claims child sexual abuse four decades ago moved forward today.

La Crosse County Circuit Judge Scott Horne denied the diocese’s motion to dismiss the complaint, in which a Plover, Wis., woman contends diocese officials knew a priest had a history of molesting children before he abused her in 1971.

Brenda Varga, now 48, met the late Rev. Raymond Bornbach in 1971 when her family attended a wedding at his church, according to the complaint. He later visited her, bringing the third-grader gifts and taking her to his house, where Varga said he molested her on and off for a year until Bornbach’s housekeeper caught him in a bedroom with her.

The diocese removed Bornbach from ministry in 2004 after the diocesan review panel found Varga’s reports credible, though Bornbach’s attorney said at the time his client denied abusing her. Bornbach died in 2006.

Varga’s suit claims then-Bishop Frederick Freking knew Bornbach had a proclivity for young girls when he was assigned in 1968 to St. Michael’s Parish in Hewitt, Wis. The complaint cites a church member who said his wife witnessed Bornbach “touching a little girl inappropriately in the church sacristy” and later reported the incident to the bishop and nuns at the parish school.

Horne ruled that placing a priest in unsupervised contact with children is the equivalent of saying he is safe.
La Crosse Tribune

Bishop Frederick Freking died 12 years ago....  Maybe we could dig him up to take the stand?

I heard this one is likely credible, as in Bishop Freking heard accusations and didn't believe them.  Sad indeed.  Fraud is a criminal charge, correct?  So are they going to charge Bishop Freking, I'm not clear on that .