Showing posts with label Intelligent Design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Intelligent Design. Show all posts

The Man Who May One-Up Darwin

On a sunny afternoon, at a bustling cafe less than a mile from Stanford University’s Palo Alto campus and more than 5,000 miles from his home, an assistant professor from MIT is telling me about science. Very advanced science. His name is Jeremy England, and at 33, he’s already being called the next Charles Darwin.

Say what?

In town to give a lecture, the Harvard grad and Rhodes scholar speaks quickly, his voice rising a few pitches in tone, his long-fingered hands making sudden jerks when he’s excited. He’s skinny, with a long face, scraggly beard and carelessly groomed mop of sandy brown hair — what you might expect from a theoretical physicist. But then there’s the street-style Adidas on his feet and the kippah atop his head. And the fact that this scientist also talks a lot about God.
Read more: The Man Who May One-Up Darwin | Rising Stars | OZY

The author is a bit unfamiliar with the issue: "While Christianity and Darwinism are generally opposed, Judaism doesn't take issue with the science of life."

Well if we look at the last century of Church documents, I don't think we can say that Catholicism is opposed to biological evolution. "Darwinism" can also connotate defined also is a religious philosophy at least in the US, similar to how scientists ascribe to something like "Spinozism."

Point being, "Intelligent Design" does not "prove" God exists.

Abbot Gregor Mendel (1822-84), Augustinian friar and founder
of genetics. Together with Darwin, he laid the groundwork for the
study of life sciences in the twentieth century.
Or how about Cardinal John Henry Newman(writing to a priest):
As to the Divine Design, is it not an instance of incomprehensibly and infinitely marvelous Wisdom and Design to have given certain laws to matter millions of ages ago, which have surely and precisely worked out, in the long course of those ages, those effects which He from the first proposed. Mr. Darwin's theory need not then to be atheistical, be it true or not; it may simply be suggesting a larger idea of Divine Prescience and Skill. Perhaps your friend has got a surer clue to guide him than I have, who have never studied the question, and I do not [see] that 'the accidental evolution of organic beings' is inconsistent with divine design—It is accidental to us, not to God.[29]
HT BL

Still made it

to AOTM despite this:


And I'll say I'm still not an Intelligent Design proponent, but Dr. Behe certainly won the debate and is quite reasonable.  I will probably read his new book that's coming out.

Essentially, the difference in the positions was that Dr. Behe believes that a Designer of nature(or perhaps simply that an intentional design exists) is provable through science, whereas Prof. Kemp believes that whether or not there was a Designer of the universe is a question that can only be answered through philosophy.

The main problem I have with ID is that if God can be "proved" through science, than He can be "disproved" through science.  But Dr. Behe does offer a much needed critique of Dick Dawkins and crew.  Ironically though they both make the same mistake, Dawkins thinks he can disprove the existence of a Designer through science whereas Behe thinks he can prove it.


Catholic Memes

Argument of the Month: Should Catholics Be Intelligent Designers? April 14th

BadgerCatholic Reply: In the negative.

As prep, I highly recommend the Response of the Pontifical Biblical Commission on Genesis -- June 30, 1909.  I remembered this being covered in the Ascension Press bible study but it took me a while to find the document.

I'm pretty sure I'm going. Ken put in the email that they were now having Mass (I think EF?) at 5:30pm before events at St. Augustine.

from AOTM

Should Catholics Be Intelligent Designers?

Catholics "believe in God, the Father almighty, maker of heaven and earth" as the Apostles' Creed puts it. He is clearly an intelligent designer if there ever was one. But should Catholics accept the arguments advanced by the school of thought known as Intelligent Design? Are they good science? Good arguments? Do they fit with the way Catholics have traditionally thought about nature and how it reveals God to us? If no on that third point, do they contradict Catholic teaching?

Dr. Michael Behe, a professor of biochemistry at Lehigh University and the author of the best-selling Darwin's Black Box and The Edge of Evolution, is one of the foremost Catholic thinkers in the Intelligent Design movement. He thinks Intelligent Design has advanced good arguments backed up by good science that comport with and support Catholic teaching about how the world provides rational evidence for God's role as an intelligent designer in the origin of species. He will argue that Intelligent Design theorists have often been misunderstood-and make the case for the solidity of ID arguments and their agreement with Catholic doctrine and thought.

Dr. Kenneth W. Kemp, a philosopher of science at the University of St. Thomas and author of numerous articles about evolution, philosophy, and theology, thinks the arguments of the Intelligent Design school for the direct role of an intelligent designer in the origin of species are not scientific arguments, are not good arguments of any sort, and don't fit with the way that Catholics have traditionally (or should now) think about nature. He will make his case for these three point and argue that, though Catholics should believe the universe as a whole is a product of Intelligent Design, they should leave ID (as an account of the origin of species) alone.

What's on the Menu
Appetizer
Homemade salsa and chips
Dinner
BBQ Pork

In addition to the pork we will be serving the kind of beans your wife and your doctor do not want you to eat! These baked beans are packed with bacon and onions! Now, no BBQ is complete with out coleslaw so there will be plenty of that and of course corn bread with a jalapeno honey glaze!

Dessert 
Fresh Baked Cookies and Ice Cream